GST Composition Scheme: When 6% Tax Can Cost More Than Regular Filing

Source: GNews Tax
Arth Insight · What this means for your wallet
- Your small business or service may be paying more GST than needed if you are under the 6% composition scheme, especially with substantial business expenses.
- Forgoing Input Tax Credit (ITC) means you lose out on savings from GST paid on your business purchases, directly impacting your profits.
- Businesses buying from you cannot claim GST credit if you are a composition dealer, potentially making your services/goods less attractive to other businesses and affecting your sales.
The Goods and Services Tax (GST) composition scheme, designed to simplify compliance for small businesses, might not always be the most cost-effective option. Businesses opting for the 6% composition rate could end up paying more tax than under the regular GST scheme, especially if their input tax credit is substantial.
- ▸The 6% GST composition scheme might cost more than regular filing if you have significant input tax credit.
- ▸Composition dealers cannot claim input tax credit, nor can their customers.
- ▸Evaluate your input costs and customer base before choosing the composition scheme.
- ▸The scheme simplifies compliance but can lead to higher net tax outgo for some businesses.
- ✓The 6% GST composition scheme might cost more than regular filing if you have significant input tax credit.
- ✓Composition dealers cannot claim input tax credit, nor can their customers.
- ✓Evaluate your input costs and customer base before choosing the composition scheme.
- ✓The scheme simplifies compliance but can lead to higher net tax outgo for some businesses.
The Goods and Services Tax (GST) composition scheme, often seen as a boon for small businesses due to its simplified compliance and lower tax rates, can sometimes prove to be a more expensive option than the regular GST filing. This counter-intuitive situation arises when the benefits of input tax credit (ITC) under the regular scheme outweigh the reduced tax rate of the composition scheme.
Under the composition scheme, businesses with an annual turnover up to ₹1.5 crore (₹75 lakh for special category states) can pay GST at a fixed rate, typically 1% for manufacturers and traders, and 6% for service providers and those supplying both goods and services. While this eliminates the need for detailed record-keeping and complex return filing, a crucial trade-off is the inability to claim input tax credit on purchases.
Understanding the 6% Composition Rate
The 6% composition rate is specifically applicable to service providers and businesses supplying both goods and services. This rate is bifurcated into 3% Central GST (CGST) and 3% State GST (SGST). The primary advantage here is the reduced compliance burden, as these businesses only need to file a quarterly statement (CMP-08) and an annual return (GSTR-4).
When 6% Becomes More Expensive
The pitfall lies in the foregone input tax credit. Businesses operating under the regular GST scheme can claim ITC on the GST paid on their raw materials, services, and other inputs. This credit effectively reduces their final GST liability. A composition dealer, however, cannot claim this credit, nor can they issue tax invoices, meaning their customers also cannot claim ITC on purchases from them.
Consider a service provider with a significant amount of input costs on which GST has been paid. If this input tax credit, when claimed under the regular scheme, results in a lower net tax payable than the 6% flat rate under the composition scheme, then opting for composition becomes financially disadvantageous. For instance, if a service provider's total GST liability under the regular scheme, after adjusting for ITC, is less than 6% of their turnover, they would be better off staying out of the composition scheme.
Impact on Customers and Business Growth
Another critical factor is the impact on customers. Businesses that purchase from a composition dealer cannot claim ITC on those purchases. This can make the composition dealer's services or goods less attractive to other GST-registered businesses, potentially impacting their market competitiveness and growth prospects. Larger businesses or those with a robust B2B client base often prefer to deal with regular GST-registered suppliers to leverage ITC benefits.
Key Considerations for Businesses
- Input Tax Credit: Evaluate the volume and value of your input purchases and the GST paid on them. If your ITC is substantial, the regular scheme might be more beneficial.
- Customer Base: If your primary customers are other GST-registered businesses, they will likely prefer you to be a regular dealer so they can claim ITC.
- Compliance Comfort vs. Cost: Weigh the ease of compliance under the composition scheme against the potential higher tax outflow and competitive disadvantages.
- Future Growth: As your business grows and your turnover approaches the ₹1.5 crore threshold, or if your input costs increase, the composition scheme may become less viable.
Businesses, especially service providers and those with mixed supplies, should carefully analyze their financial structure, input costs, and customer profile before opting for or continuing with the 6% GST composition scheme. A thorough calculation comparing the net tax payable under both schemes is essential to ensure they are not paying more than they save.
This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute tax or financial advice. Consult a qualified tax professional for personalized guidance.
Tax figures shown are indicative estimates for education only and depend on your specific situation. Consult a qualified tax professional or the Income-Tax Department before acting.
Frequently Asked Questions
Who is eligible for the 6% GST composition scheme?
The 6% GST composition scheme is applicable to service providers and businesses supplying both goods and services, with an annual turnover up to ₹1.5 crore (₹75 lakh for special category states).
What is the main disadvantage of the GST composition scheme?
The main disadvantage is that businesses under the composition scheme cannot claim input tax credit (ITC) on their purchases, and they cannot issue tax invoices, meaning their customers also cannot claim ITC.
How can a business determine if the 6% composition scheme is right for them?
Businesses should compare their net tax payable under the regular GST scheme (after claiming ITC) with the 6% flat rate under the composition scheme. They should also consider their customer base and the impact of not being able to pass on ITC benefits.
Join the Arth Vani channels
Daily news summaries, IPO & market alerts on Telegram and WhatsApp.
Because you read about Taxation
BreakingGovernment Seeks Stakeholder Feedback on Proposed GST Return System Reforms
The Indian government has initiated a process to gather inputs from businesses and other stakeholders regarding potential changes to the Goods and Services Tax (GST) return filing system. This move aims to simplify compliance and enhance the efficiency of the indirect tax regime.

Government Seeks Stakeholder Input on Proposed GST Return System Changes
The Indian government has initiated a process to gather feedback from various stakeholders regarding proposed modifications to the Goods and Services Tax (GST) return filing system. This move aims to streamline the existing compliance mechanism and enhance ease of doing business for taxpayers across the country.
BreakingGST Relief: No New Pre-Deposit Needed for GSTAT Appeals if 20% Tax Already Paid
Taxpayers appealing to the GST Appellate Tribunal (GSTAT) do not need to make fresh pre-deposits if their previous deposits already cover 20% of the disputed tax amount. This clarification simplifies the litigation process for businesses and individuals contesting tax demands.
Related Stories
BreakingGovernment Seeks Stakeholder Feedback on Proposed GST Return System Reforms
The Indian government has initiated a process to gather inputs from businesses and other stakeholders regarding potential changes to the Goods and Services Tax (GST) return filing system. This move aims to simplify compliance and enhance the efficiency of the indirect tax regime.

Government Seeks Stakeholder Input on Proposed GST Return System Changes
The Indian government has initiated a process to gather feedback from various stakeholders regarding proposed modifications to the Goods and Services Tax (GST) return filing system. This move aims to streamline the existing compliance mechanism and enhance ease of doing business for taxpayers across the country.
BreakingGST Relief: No New Pre-Deposit Needed for GSTAT Appeals if 20% Tax Already Paid
Taxpayers appealing to the GST Appellate Tribunal (GSTAT) do not need to make fresh pre-deposits if their previous deposits already cover 20% of the disputed tax amount. This clarification simplifies the litigation process for businesses and individuals contesting tax demands.

Three Convicted in Kerala's ₹26.58 Lakh Commercial Tax Fraud Case
A Kerala court has convicted three individuals in a commercial tax fraud case involving ₹26.58 lakh. The conviction follows a lengthy investigation into fraudulent tax claims. This case highlights the serious consequences of tax evasion in India.